No evidence that elevated CO2 gives tropical lianas an advantage over tropical trees
Marvin DC; Winter K; Burnham RJ; Schnitzer SA
Global Change Biology
Recent studies indicate that lianas are increasing in size and abundance relative to trees in neotropical forests. As a result forest dynamics and carbon balance may be altered through liana-induced suppression of tree growth and increases in tree mortality. Increasing atmospheric CO2 is hypothesized to be responsible for the increase in neotropical lianas yet no study has directly compared the relative response of tropical lianas and trees to elevated CO2. We explicitly tested whether tropical lianas had a larger response to elevated CO2 than co-occurring tropical trees and whether seasonal drought alters the response of either growth form. In two experiments conducted in central Panama one spanning both wet and dry seasons and one restricted to the dry season we grew liana (n=12) and tree (n=10) species in open-top growth chambers maintained at ambient or twice-ambient CO2 levels. Seedlings of eight individuals (four lianas four trees) were grown in the ground in each chamber for at least three months during each season. We found that both liana and tree seedlings had a significant and positive response to elevated CO2 (in biomass leaf area leaf mass per area and photosynthesis) but that the relative response to elevated CO2 for all variables was not significantly greater for lianas than trees regardless of the season. The lack of differences in the relative response between growth forms does not support the hypothesis that elevated CO2 is responsible for increasing liana size and abundance across the neotropics.